Reader's Choice Awards: Thank you for your votes – we WON!

We have won for the last 16yrs so please help us win this year.

We’ve been voted Reader’s Choice for the past 16 years! Support us again this year by clicking here.

Metal Roofing and Asphalt Shingles in Piqua, OH

Call Us Today

Request a Service

Loading form…


Metal roofing in Piqua has moved from barns and machine sheds onto plenty of houses in town, and many owners now weigh it against a fresh set of asphalt shingles. Rich Roofing & Services installs both, so we have no reason to push one over the other. Our crew comes up from Troy, a few minutes down I-75, and we have been roofing the Miami Valley since 1965.


Piqua makes the choice interesting. The tall homes from the late 1800s near downtown suit the look of shingles, while ranches on the edges of town and outbuildings on rural lots are natural fits for metal.


Already know the old roof has to come off? Our Piqua roof replacement page walks through the tear-off and rebuild.


Contact us

Comparing Metal and Shingles for a Piqua House


Here is how metal roofing in Piqua stacks up against shingles on the questions homeowners ask first.

Lifespan: a well-installed metal roof usually lasts much longer than a shingle roof. Architectural shingles still give a long service life when the attic is vented properly.


Price today versus later: shingles cost less on day one. Metal costs more up front, which can even out if you stay in the house for many years.

Snow and ice: metal sheds snow fast, which helps with ice at the eaves but calls for snow guards above doors, steps and driveways.


Hail and wind: big hail can dent metal, usually just on the surface, and it can crack shingles. Properly fastened panels resist wind lift well.

Looks: shingles blend with most older homes in town. Metal reads more modern, though darker colors and narrow panels can suit a farmhouse well.


Asphalt Shingles on Piqua's Victorian and Mid-Century Homes


Shingles remain the most common roof in Piqua for good reasons. The thicker dimensional kind stands up to wind better than the old flat three-tab style and gives the roof more depth and shadow.


They also handle the complicated rooflines on older homes near Caldwell Street and High Street: turrets, dormers, valleys and porch roofs that tie into the main slope. Metal can do those details, but each one costs more to form.


If you just need a few shingles replaced, our Piqua roof repair crew can match them as closely as possible.



How We Help You Choose a Roof Material in Piqua

Choosing metal roofing in Piqua or shingles is part of every free estimate. This is the order we go in.

Checking Slope, Deck and Attic

Low slopes, weak decking or poor ventilation can rule an option in or out before we ever talk about color.

Holding Samples Against Your House

We bring panel and shingle samples so you can see them next to your brick, siding and trim.

Two Written Prices

When both materials work, you get both prices, upfront, so the comparison is fair.

Talking Through Noise and Comfort

Over solid decking with underlayment and insulation, rain on metal sounds much like rain on shingles. We explain how we keep it quiet.

Planning Edges and Trim for Metal

Metal over entries and walkways gets snow guards, and each edge gets trim made for the panel profile.

Setting the Install Date

Once you decide, we schedule the job and handle the tear-off if the old roof has to come off first.

Standing Seam and Exposed-Fastener Metal Around Piqua


A standing seam roof hides its fasteners under raised seams, so no screws face the weather. It costs more, looks clean and is the usual choice for a house.


Exposed-fastener panels cost less and are common on pole barns, garages and sheds along the rural roads outside Piqua. The screws and washers need checking over the years, and our steel roof services cover that upkeep.


Building a new garage or addition with no roof yet? That is new construction rather than a replacement, and our Piqua roofing contractor page explains how we handle it.

With metal roofing in Piqua, we plan gutters and guards together so sliding snow and leaves do not tear them loose. See our Piqua gutter guard options.

Metal and Shingle Roofs for Piqua, Covington and Fletcher


We install metal roofing in Piqua and nearby in Troy, Covington, Fletcher, Lockington and Sidney. If you have been searching for metal roofing near me in northern Miami County, we are a short drive away.


We are licensed and certified, family-run, and Latino-owned and Veteran-owned. Read customer comments on our reviews page, learn who we are, or book a Piqua roof inspection to see what your roof can support.

Piqua Metal Roof Questions, Answered


Still choosing? A free look at your roof helps narrow it down.

Contact us now
  • Is metal roofing in Piqua worth the extra cost?

    It can be if you plan to stay a long time. Metal lasts longer and needs less upkeep, but shingles cost less up front. We price both so you can decide.

  • Can a metal roof go over my old shingles?

    Sometimes, but we usually prefer to tear off and look at the deck first, especially on older Piqua homes.

  • Are metal roofs loud in the rain?

    Not when installed over solid decking with underlayment and an insulated attic. Most homeowners say it sounds much like shingles.

  • Will a metal roof attract lightning?

    No. A metal roof does not make a lightning strike more likely.

  • Which shingles do you recommend?

    We usually recommend architectural shingles for their thickness and wind resistance. We will show you colors that suit your home.

  • Do you install metal on barns and outbuildings?

    Yes. Exposed-fastener panels are a common, budget-friendly choice for barns, garages and sheds.

  • Does metal roofing help with energy bills?

    Lighter colors reflect more summer heat, which can help keep an attic cooler. Results depend on insulation and ventilation.

  • How do I get a price for both options?

    Contact us to set up a free estimate, and we will give you written prices for metal and shingles. If you have been calling metal roofers near me, add us to the list.