Reader's Choice Awards: Thank you for your votes – we WON!

We have won for the last 16yrs so please help us win this year.

We’ve been voted Reader’s Choice for the past 16 years! Support us again this year by clicking here.

Metal Roofing and Asphalt Shingles in Dayton, OH

Call Us Today

Request a Service

Loading form…


Choosing between metal roofing in Dayton and a new set of asphalt shingles comes down to the house, the budget and how long you plan to stay. Rich Roofing & Services installs both, and we lay out the trade-offs plainly so the choice is yours.


Dayton's housing stock makes the question interesting. A 1910s two-story in Dayton View or St. Anne's Hill has steep slopes and a look that suits shingles, while its porch roof, a bay window or the detached garage out back can carry metal that sheds snow and lasts.


We are a family roofer from Troy and have been putting roofs on Miami Valley homes since 1965.


Contact us

Metal Roof vs Shingles on a Dayton House


Here is how metal roofing in Dayton compares with shingles on the things homeowners ask about most.

Upfront cost: shingles cost less to put on. Metal costs more at the start but usually outlasts a shingle roof, so the price per year can land closer than the sticker suggests.


Weight: both are light enough for a typical house frame. Metal panels weigh less than shingles, which helps on an older roof structure.

Noise: over a solid deck with underlayment and an insulated attic, rain on metal sounds much like rain on shingles. The tin-roof racket people picture comes from barns with open rafters.


Hail: large hail can dent metal panels, usually cosmetically, and it can crack or bruise shingles. Neither material is hail-proof.

Snow and ice: metal sheds snow quickly, which cuts down on ice at the eaves but calls for snow guards over doors and walkways. Shingles hold snow longer.


Architectural Shingles for Dayton's Older Two-Story Homes


Plenty of Dayton homes still go back with shingles, and for good reason. Architectural shingles are thicker than the old three-tab kind, hold up better in wind and give a roof the layered look that suits brick and clapboard houses from the early 1900s.


They also work around the details older homes are full of: dormers, valleys, chimneys and the porch roof tying into the main slope. Shingles are only part of the system, and the flashing, vents and gutters that go with them are covered on our Dayton residential roofing page.


If you have already settled on shingles and the old roof is ready to come off, our roof replacement work in Dayton page explains how that job runs.



Picking the Right Roof Material for Your Dayton Home, Step by Step

Material choice is part of every free estimate we give. This is how we help you decide.

Looking at the Roof and Attic First

We check slope, decking, ventilation and how many layers are already on the house. Some of those answers rule a material in or out before we ever talk price.

Showing Panels Next to Shingle Samples

You see standing seam and exposed-fastener metal beside shingle samples, in colors that suit your brick or siding.

Pricing Both Options Side by Side

When both make sense, you get both prices, upfront, so the comparison is honest.

Matching Colors to a Historic Block

On streets with a strong historic look, we point out which colors and profiles fit in. If your street has its own rules, check those before you choose.

Planning Snow Guards and Trim for Metal

Metal over doors, drives and walks gets snow guards, and every edge gets trim made for the panel profile.

Scheduling Once You Have Decided

You choose the material and the date. If the old roof is coming off first, that part is handled as a replacement job.

Standing Seam Metal Roofs Around Dayton


A standing seam metal roof hides its fasteners under raised seams, so no screws sit exposed to the weather. It costs more than exposed-fastener panels and suits homes where the roof is part of the look. Read more about how steel roofs are made.


For metal roofing in Dayton, standing seam fits best on lower-slope additions, porch roofs, bay windows and newer homes, and on any house the owner plans to keep for decades. Big trees over the roof are a point in its favor, since leaves and maple seeds slide right off.


Exposed-fastener panels cost less and are common on garages and outbuildings. Their screws need checking over the years, and our steel roof repair for Dayton crew handles that when they loosen.

Building something new, like an addition or a garage that has no roof yet? That is a new roof installation in Dayton, and either material works.

Metal and Shingle Roofs for Kettering, Oakwood and Riverside


We install metal roofing in Dayton and the towns around it: Kettering, Oakwood, Riverside, Trotwood, Huber Heights and Vandalia. If you were searching metal roofing near me or metal roofers near me from one of those places, you are in our area.


We are licensed and certified, family-run, and Latino-owned and Veteran-owned. Read what homeowners say on our reviews page, or ask for a free estimate Monday through Friday, 8 to 5.

Dayton Roofing Material Questions, Answered


Still deciding? A free roof inspection in Dayton tells you what your deck and attic can take before you pick.

Contact us now
  • Is metal roofing in Dayton worth the higher price?

    It can be if you plan to stay in the house a long time, since a metal roof usually outlasts shingles and needs less upkeep. If you might sell in a few years, shingles often make more sense.

  • Will a metal roof look out of place on an older Dayton home?

    Not always. A dark standing seam porch or addition often looks right on an older house while the main roof stays in shingles. We show you examples in colors that fit.

  • Are architectural shingles better than three-tab shingles?

    For most homes, yes. They are thicker, handle wind better and give the roof more depth for a modest difference in price.

  • Does a metal roof make the house hotter or cooler?

    Metal reflects more sun than dark shingles, especially in lighter colors, which can help keep an attic cooler in summer. Attic insulation and ventilation still do most of the work.

  • Can metal go right over my existing shingles?

    Sometimes, but on older Dayton homes we usually want to see the deck first. We check what is under there before giving you options.

  • Do metal roofs attract lightning?

    No. Metal does not make a strike more likely, and if lightning does hit, a metal roof will not catch fire.

  • What colors can I choose from?

    Both metal panels and shingles come in a wide range. We bring samples so you can see them against your brick or siding in daylight.

  • How do I price metal roofing in Dayton against shingles?

    Call or send a message and we will set up a free visit. You get prices for metal and for shingles side by side, so the decision is easy to make.